John McGarr

508.577.5450

ADDRESS

37 MAIN ST
NANTUCKET MA 02554

Follow Me

Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Browse Homes

  • John McGarr

    Nantucket Real Estate Expert

Start Your Real Estate Journey

Whether working with buyers or sellers, John McGarr provides outstanding professionalism into making her client’s real estate dreams a reality.

White-shingled home with a tall stone chimney, covered porch, and manicured lawn.

Portfolio

 Furnished living room with a white sofa, blue and ochre pillows, and framed landscape art.

Home Valuation

 Sailboat underway, with cream sails filling the frame above choppy water.

Let's Connect

John McGarr

John McGarr in a patterned blazer and open-collar shirt.

Meet John

John grew up in Groton, MA. His experience in sales, marketing, and business development has been broad-based with a focus on leveraging technology.

He's been successful as a multi-line sales representative for 16 Winter Sports manufacturers servicing roughly 180 stores, VP of Sales for Glass Eye Media (web development), Director of Business Development for M2 Discovery (voice discovery), and the VP of Siren Marine (M2M) the winner of the RI Business Plan Competition Technology Award and Overall Winner 2012, and recently purchased by Yamaha Motor Company. Whether buying, selling, renting, or simply curious about Nantucket, John is your man.

Learn More
License
#9533691

Testimonials

John has been a great resource for me in exploring rental options and purchase options in Nantucket. I wasn't real sure of the landscape of the island in terms of what is available, what areas of the island would fit best for me, the possibilities and availability of long-term rentals vs short term, etc. John has been able to guide me through this difficult process and his knowledge of the island is vast. On top of that he is a pleasure to work with. I honestly could not recommend anyone more!
John has been a great resource for me in exploring rental options and purchase options in Nantucket. I wasn't real sure of the landscape of the island in terms of what is available, what areas of the island would fit best for me, the possibilities and availability of long-term rentals vs short term, etc. John has been able to guide me through this difficult process and his knowledge of the island is vast. On top of that he is a pleasure to work with. I honestly could not recommend anyone more!
Nick V.
I can't speak highly enough of my experience with working with John McGarr, who helped me find a great rental property. From the get-go, he was super responsive, offered plenty of options in line with our needs, and made the process of finding a rental simple, pleasant, and hassle-free. I'd definitely work with John again for my next rental (hopefully, even a sale someday!), and I'd recommend him to anyone who's looking for a great realtor.
I can't speak highly enough of my experience with working with John McGarr, who helped me find a great rental property. From the get-go, he was super responsive, offered plenty of options in line with our needs, and made the process of finding a rental simple, pleasant, and hassle-free. I'd definitely work with John again for my next rental (hopefully, even a sale someday!), and I'd recommend him to anyone who's looking for a great realtor.
Buyer
Not that long in the business but learning fast with Windwalker, an excellent Nantucket real estate office. Very computer app. knowledgeable. Extremely agreeable to work with; likable personality. Handled our transaction ($2.5 million sale) smoothly; also an earlier purchase on Nantucket for some friends of ours.
Not that long in the business but learning fast with Windwalker, an excellent Nantucket real estate office. Very computer app. knowledgeable. Extremely agreeable to work with; likable personality. Handled our transaction ($2.5 million sale) smoothly; also an earlier purchase on Nantucket for some friends of ours.
Hugh D.
John was knowledgeable, flexible and thorough. He knows the market extremely well and stays current on all the local developments and changes. He was dedicated to satisfying our search agenda. He was available whenever we needed him and had time to answer all our questions. I have recommended John to friends and will always strongly encourage people use John when looking for a home.
John was knowledgeable, flexible and thorough. He knows the market extremely well and stays current on all the local developments and changes. He was dedicated to satisfying our search agenda. He was available whenever we needed him and had time to answer all our questions. I have recommended John to friends and will always strongly encourage people use John when looking for a home.
Buyer
View All

Portfolio

  • Aerial view of a shingled coastal home with a lit swimming pool, spa, and broad lawn. For Sale

    $19,950,000

    36 Warrens Landing Road

    36 Warrens Landing Road, Nantucket, MA 02554

    • 7 Beds
    • 11 Baths
    • 6,488 Sq.Ft.
  • Aerial view of 8 Old Westmoor Farm Road, with an outlined wooded parcel near the coast. Rent

    $10,928,300

    8 Old Westmoor Farm Road

    8 Old Westmoor Farm Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554

  • Aerial view of a shingle-style home with a swimming pool, detached garage, and ocean on the horizon. Sold

    $7,500,000

    196 Cliff Road

    196 Cliff Road, Nantucket, MA 02554

    • 5 Beds
    • 5 Baths
    • 3,788 Sq.Ft.
  • Gray shingle-style home with a bay window behind a leafy garden and white picket fence. Sold

    $6,100,000

    8 Milk Street

    8 Milk Street, Nantucket, MA 02554

    • 4 Beds
    • 5 Baths
    • 2,744 Sq.Ft.
View All

Get your instant home valuation

Enter your details to see how much your home is worth.
  • Instant result
  • Sell for more
  • Get expert advice
Luxury Presence Home Value

Property Address

Address

dummy-map
How we calculate your estimate
How we calculate your estimate

Luxury Presence Home Value is the current estimated value of this home. It is calculated from a comprehensive database which encompasses properties from all 50 states, covering 99% of the US population, and valuation software developed by Automated Valuation Model (AVM) Analytics.

Large cedar-shingle home with white balconies, a brick chimney, flowering shrubs, and a gravel driveway.

How much is your home worth?

  • Instant property valuation
  • Expert advice
  • Sell for more
Loading valuation...

Neighborhoods

  • Beach Plum
  • Eel Point
  • Fishers Landing
  • Tom Nevers
  • Madequecham
  • Polpis
  • Cisco/Hummock Pond
  • Cliff
  • Naushop
  • Quidnet/Squam
  • Wauwinet
  • Miacomet
  • Surfside
  • Pocomo
  • Town
  • Siasconset
  • Brant Point
  • Madaket
  • Monomoy
  • Dionis
  • Beach Plum

    Explore Beach Plum

    Read More
  • Eel Point beach with rolling surf and coastal houses along the shore.

    Explore Eel Point

    Read More
  • Fishers Landing waterfront cottages stand on a wooden wharf above calm harbor water.

    Explore Fishers Landing

    Read More
  • Large cedar-shingle house with wraparound porch, dormers, and flowering hydrangeas.

    Explore Tom Nevers

    Tom Nevers is a more secluded area with lots of beautiful open space and areas of thick woodland.

    Read More
  • Waterfront shingle building behind a dock lined with bicycles and flower planters.

    Explore Madequecham

    Travel down a long and dusty road to reach the legendary Madequecham beach. Depending on the weather and the tides

    Read More
  • A grassy two-track lane between shingled cottages, lined with white fences and gardens.

    Explore Polpis

    Polpis is home to Nantucket’s working cranberry bogs as well as nature paths among the wildlife.

    Read More
  • Sunset over Hummock Pond, with reeds in the foreground and orange light reflecting on the water.

    Explore Cisco/Hummock Pond

    Stop at Cisco Brewers (kids and dogs welcome) for live music and indulge in local craft beer, wine and spirits.

    Read More
  • Aerial view of a sandy coastline with breaking waves, green dunes, and scattered houses.

    Explore Cliff

    Just on the outskirts of town, walking to restaurants and shopping is quick and convenient.

    Read More
  • Naushop

    Explore Naushop

    Naushop is a quaint and classic neighborhood with white fences, brick driveways and well-manicured landscaping.

    Read More
  • Hillside homes overlooking a manicured golf course under a clear blue sky.

    Explore Quidnet/Squam

    A flawless summer retreat, Quidnet is quiet and pristine and surrounded by conservation land.

    Read More
  • Wauwinet beach with dune stairs, beach houses, and American flags.

    Explore Wauwinet

    Wauwinet sits nestled between water- the Atlantic Ocean on one side and the Harbor on the other.

    Read More
  • Sandy path through Miacomet’s grassy dunes leading to the ocean at golden hour.

    Explore Miacomet

    If you love spending time outdoors, Miacomet is the place for you. Spend a day on Miacomet Golf Course- a public 18-hole exquisitely scenic and manicured.

    Read More
  • A seagull flies over beachside sailboats, with green dunes and coastal homes in the background.

    Explore Surfside

    This idyllic beachside community is renowned for its pristine sandy shores, where the rhythmic waves of the Atlantic Ocean meet the soft, powdery sand.

    Read More
  • Harbor with small boats and distant shore homes, seen over flowering coastal vegetation.

    Explore Pocomo

    This is a popular spot to either participate in or watch kite boarders and windsurfers zip along the vibrant blue waters.

    Read More
  • Town

    Explore Town

    If you desire being among high energy in the heart of Nantucket, town is the right place for you.

    Read More
  • Wooden bridge leads between shingled coastal homes toward the ocean.

    Explore Siasconset

    Siasconset, or simply referred to by locals as ‘Sconset, is a town located on the East end of the island.

    Read More
  • Brant Point Lighthouse beside the beach, with a white walkway and American flag.

    Explore Brant Point

    The location allows for a quick walk into the heart of town, or for leisurely strolls past oceanfront homes and Brant Point Lighthouse.

    Read More
  • Madaket beach dunes and shoreline in warm evening light.

    Explore Madaket

    Be sure to stop at Millie’s for a fish taco and a Madaket Mystery and have a front seat sunset experience.

    Read More
  • Monomoy inlet with marsh grass, moored boats, a dock, and waterfront homes.

    Explore Monomoy

    Monomoy is a quiet and picturesque neighborhood with spectacular views of the Harbor and the Town’s magnificent skyline.

    Read More
  • Shingle-style coastal home above a beach, with a timber seawall and flags.

    Explore Dionis

    With acres of conservation land, grand waterfront estates, and the calm waters of Nantucket Sound, Dionis offers full immersion into the beauty of Nantucket.

    Read More
View All

Follow Me On Instagram

White two-story house with a covered porch, attached garage, and tiered stone retaining walls.

Get in Touch

JOHN MCGARR

508.577.5450

ADDRESS 37 MAIN ST NANTUCKET MA 02554

Get in Touch

Enter a valid email

Get in Touch

JOHN MCGARR

508.577.5450

ADDRESS 37 MAIN ST NANTUCKET MA 02554